The controversy surrounding natural morganite doesn’t stem from the way it looks—it’s truly a beautiful gemstone that comes in many different shades of pink, purple and blue depending on the trace amounts of manganese it contains. The real problem, however, lies in how it is obtained.
What Is Morganite?
Morganite, also known as pink beryl, is a gem that can be found in various shades of pink. The most common types are peach and raspberry, but there are other colors like lavender or even white. This gem’s color comes from its trace amounts of chromium and vanadium. In jewelry, morganite can be used as a substitute for natural emerald because they have a similar luster and hardness. However, some people say this stone is actually an imitation of emerald because it only has traces of chromium and vanadium while emeralds contain both chromium and vanadium.
The Debate: Is Morganite A Real Gemstone?
Morganite, a colorless gemstone, gets its name from the morgana flower. The gem has a long and interesting history as it was first discovered in 1958 by George D. Kunz who mistook it for an emerald. In 1960, Walter Schumann confirmed that morganite was not an emerald and named it after his friend, John Pierpont Morgan Jr., a noted mineral collector of these stones.
Morganites are often confused with natural emeralds because they both have a greenish tinge to them which is why many people believe they are the same stone.
The Pros Of Morganite
Morganite, a pinkish-purple gemstone that gets its name from the mineral morganite, is a relatively new gem to the market. It has many natural qualities that make it a popular choice for jewelry. For starters, morganite gets its pinkish-purple hue from traces of chromium, while natural emeralds are green due to their composition of iron and chromium. In addition, morganite is easier to create than emeralds because it doesn’t require any heat treatment and can be cut in any shape or size without losing its color. The best part about this gemstone? It’s affordable!
The Cons Of Morganite
Morganite, otherwise known as pink emerald, is a gemstone that is not entirely natural. Many people are fooled by its look because it can be found in different colors and has similar properties to a natural emerald. The only difference between these two gems, however, is that morganite does not have the same origin as a natural emerald. In other words, morganite isn’t mined like an emerald would be. Instead, morganites are created artificially in laboratories and manufactured to mimic the appearance of a natural emerald. This makes many people question whether or not morganites are real gems at all. So why bother with this controversial gemstone if it doesn’t exist naturally?
The Bottom Line
The stone was first discovered in Madagascar, but it has also been found in other locations. The most notable of these is Burma (now Myanmar), where it was misnamed Pigeon’s Blood because of its striking red color and black speckles. Morganite has a hardness on Mohs scale of 7 to 7-1/2 and is composed of silicon dioxide. Natural Emerald has a hardness on Mohs scale of 6 to 7 and contains chromium, iron, manganese, nickel, and vanadium.
Morganite can be confused with natural emerald due to their similar chemical composition, but there are three ways to distinguish the two.